BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King or BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen? Which BedStory Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between the bedstory 10 inch medium firm king vs 12 inch extra firm queen depends on your size and support needs. Both models are hybrid mattresses with individually wrapped pocket coils and gel-infused memory foam. They share CertiPUR-US certification and a fiberglass-free design. The main difference lies in firmness and thickness. One offers a medium firm feel at ten inches. The other provides an extra firm feel at twelve inches. Each targets different sleep preferences and body types.
Key differences
| Aspect | BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King Hybrid Mattress | BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress |
|---|---|---|
| Size | King (76 x 80 inches) | Queen (60 x 80 inches) |
| Firmness | Medium Firm | Extra Firm |
| Thickness | 10 inches | 12 inches |
| Color | White | Khaki |
| Weight | 75 pounds | 88 pounds |
| Special Features | Bed in a Box | Intended Use: Back Pain Relief |
Which one should you choose?
Choose BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King Hybrid Mattress if
- You need a wider sleeping surface for two people.
- You prefer a medium firm feel that balances cushioning with support.
- You want a lighter mattress that is easier to move.
Choose BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress if
- You prefer a firmer surface for strict spinal alignment.
- You need extra thickness for enhanced pressure relief on hips and shoulders.
- You are a back sleeper seeking maximum lumbar support.
Verdict: The 10-inch King model suits couples who want ample space and a balanced medium firm feel. The 12-inch Queen model is better for single sleepers or those needing extra firm support for back pain. Choose based on your preferred firmness level and bed size requirements.
BedStory King vs Queen Comparison
Firmness Level
The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King offers a medium firm feel, which provides balanced support for back sleepers and larger body types. It aims to reduce motion transfer while maintaining stable comfort. In contrast, the BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is designed for those who prefer a much harder surface. This extra firm construction helps prevent excessive sink and promotes spinal alignment, making it suitable for individuals needing strong lumbar support. You should choose the medium firm option if you want a softer, more conforming feel, or the extra firm model if you need rigid support to keep your spine straight.
Thickness and Height
Thickness is a clear differentiator between these two models. The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King sits at 10 inches tall, providing a standard profile that fits most bed frames. The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is two inches taller, standing at 12 inches. This additional height often correlates with more comfort layers or a thicker support core, which can enhance the overall feel of the mattress. If you prefer a taller mattress that sits higher off the ground, the 12-inch Queen is the better choice. If you want a standard height that is easier to make up, the 10-inch King is sufficient.
Mattress Construction
Both mattresses use a hybrid construction combining foam and pocket coils, but the specific details vary. The 10-Inch King uses 2.3mm individually wrapped pocket coils and gel-infused memory foam, with a reinforced edge framework to prevent roll-off. The 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen also features individually wrapped pocket coils and cooling gel memory foam, but it highlights a 60% stronger reinforced hybrid structure. This stronger build in the Queen model is designed to resist sagging and maintain consistent firmness over time. Both designs boost air circulation for cooling, but the King includes specific zoned targeted pressure balance in its coil system.
Color and Aesthetics
The visual appearance of the mattresses differs based on the model. The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King is white, which is a common color for many hybrid mattresses. The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen comes in khaki. This difference is purely aesthetic and does not affect performance. You might prefer the white cover for a classic, bright look, or the khaki cover for a more neutral, earthy tone. Since both are covered in similar materials, the color choice depends entirely on your bedroom decor preferences. Neither color impacts the cooling properties or support levels of the sleep surface.
Certifications and Safety
Safety certifications are similar for both products. The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King holds CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certifications, ensuring the foam is free from harmful chemicals like ozone depleters, mercury, lead, formaldehyde, and phthalates. It is also fiberglass-free. The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is CertiPUR-US certified and fiberglass-free. While both meet high safety standards for foam quality, the King model explicitly lists OEKO-TEX certification, which covers the textile components as well. If you prioritize third-party textile safety verification, the King has a slight edge. Both models ensure a clean sleeping environment without harmful emissions.
Weight and Capacity
The weight of the mattresses differs due to their size and construction. The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King weighs 75 pounds. The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is heavier at 88 pounds. This extra weight in the Queen model likely results from the additional two inches of material and the stronger reinforced hybrid structure. Both mattresses support a 600 lbs weight capacity. The heavier Queen may be more difficult to move or rotate, while the lighter King is easier to handle. If you need a mattress that is easier to maneuver, the King is the practical choice. If you do not mind the extra weight for a sturdier feel, the Queen is suitable.
Which BedStory Hybrid Fits Your Sleep Style
Couples needing motion isolation and space
This King size model measures 76 inches wide, offering ample sleeping area for two people. Its medium firm feel balances support and comfort. The 2.3mm individually wrapped pocket coils reduce motion transfer effectively. This helps prevent disturbance when your partner moves, ensuring undisturbed rest throughout the night.
Back sleepers requiring strong lumbar support
The extra firm construction targets spinal alignment for back sleepers. This 12-inch thickness provides a stable surface that resists excessive sink. The reinforced pocket coil core supports the natural curve of your spine. This design helps relieve pressure on your lower back while maintaining proper posture during sleep.
Hot sleepers preferring cooler airflow
This Queen model features an open coil structure that enhances airflow between layers. The cooling gel memory foam comfort layer helps regulate temperature. The 12-inch height allows for more air circulation than thinner options. These specs work together to dissipate heat and moisture for a cooler sleep surface.
Side sleepers wanting pressure relief
The medium firm feel offers a gentler surface for side sleepers. The zoned pocket coils provide differentiated support for shoulders and hips. This segmented design evenly disperses body weight to maintain natural spinal posture. The gel-infused foam adds comfort without compromising the steady support needed for joint relief.
The products compared
BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King Hybrid Mattress
Best for: back sleepers wanting balanced support
- Size
- King (U.S. Standard)
- Thickness
- 10 inches
- Firmness
- Medium Firm
- Mattress Construction
- Pocket spring hybrid
- Support Core
- 2.3mm individual pocket coils
- Comfort Layer
- Gel-infused memory foam
View on Amazon: BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King Hybrid Mattress Affiliate link
This BedStory hybrid mattress offers 10 inches of height with a medium firm feel. It uses 2.3mm individually wrapped pocket coils and gel-infused memory foam. The design targets spinal alignment and motion isolation. It supports up to 600 lbs and includes reinforced edges. This model suits back sleepers and couples seeking stable, balanced support without excessive sinkage.
Pros
- Medium firm feel for balanced support
- 2.3mm individually wrapped pocket coils
- Gel-infused memory foam comfort layer
- 600 lbs weight capacity
- Reinforced edge support framework
Cons
- 10-inch profile is thinner than the 12-inch alternative
- Medium firmness may feel too soft for strict side sleepers
- No remote or smart connectivity features
Good fit if
- You prefer a medium firm surface for back sleeping
- You need a mattress with strong edge support
- You want motion isolation for shared beds
Skip if
- You require an extra firm feel for heavy body types
- You prefer a taller 12-inch or 14-inch profile
- You need smart features or app control
Verdict: BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King delivers steady support through its 2.3mm pocket coils and gel foam. It fits back sleepers and couples who prioritize motion isolation and edge stability over maximum height.
BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress
Best for: Back and side sleepers needing firm support
- Size
- Queen
- Thickness
- 12 in
- Firmness
- Extra Firm
- Mattress Construction
- Hybrid foam and pocket coils
- Support Core
- Individually wrapped pocket coils
- Comfort Layer
- Cooling gel memory foam
View on Amazon: BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress Affiliate link
This BedStory 12-inch hybrid mattress combines individually wrapped pocket coils with cooling gel memory foam. It features an extra firm feel designed to support spinal alignment and reduce pressure points. The 12-inch height and 88-pound weight provide a stable base. CertiPUR-US certified foams ensure material safety. This model suits back and side sleepers seeking firm support and motion isolation for undisturbed rest.
Pros
- Individually wrapped pocket coils for targeted support
- Cooling gel memory foam comfort layer
- Extra firm feel for spinal alignment
- CertiPUR-US certified and fiberglass-free
Cons
- Extra firm feel may not suit soft-bed lovers
- 88-pound weight makes moving difficult
- No smart features or app control listed
Good fit if
- You prefer a firm sleeping surface
- You need strong lumbar support
- You share the bed and want motion isolation
Skip if
- You prefer a plush or soft feel
- You need adjustable firmness settings
- You require smart connectivity features
Verdict: BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen delivers stable support through its hybrid coil and foam build. It fits back and side sleepers who need firm alignment and cooler sleep.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King Hybrid Mattress | BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen Hybrid Mattress |
|---|---|---|
| Size | King (U.S. Standard) | Queen |
| Thickness | 10 inches | 12 in |
| Firmness | Medium Firm | Extra Firm |
| Mattress Construction | Pocket spring hybrid | Hybrid foam and pocket coils |
| Support Core | 2.3mm individual pocket coils | Individually wrapped pocket coils |
| Comfort Layer | Gel-infused memory foam | Cooling gel memory foam |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US, OEKO-TEX, fiberglass-free | CertiPUR-US certified, fiberglass free |
| Special Features | Zoned support, edge support | not stated |
| Intended Use | Back sleepers, larger body types | not stated |
| Cover Material | not stated | Cooling Gel |
| Color | White | Khaki |
| Dimensions | 80 × 76 × 10 inches | 80 × 60 × 12 inches |
| Weight | 75 pounds | 88 pounds |
| Model | P2603124 | P2303297 |
Frequently asked questions
Is the BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King good for back sleepers?
Yes, this model is designed for back sleepers seeking balanced support. Its medium firm feel works with 2.3mm pocket coils to maintain spinal alignment. The gel foam layer adds comfort without compromising the steady support needed for proper posture during sleep.
Does the BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen help with back pain?
This mattress lists back pain relief as a special feature. The extra firm construction provides stable support for back and side sleepers. Its hybrid coil and foam build aims to keep your spine aligned, which can help reduce pressure points and discomfort.
Which BedStory mattress is better for couples?
The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King is better for couples due to its larger size. It measures 76 inches wide, offering ample space for two people. The individually wrapped pocket coils also help isolate motion, so you are less likely to feel your partner move.
How thick is the BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen?
The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is 12 inches tall. This extra height provides more cushioning and support layers compared to the 10-inch King model. The increased thickness helps distribute weight evenly, which is beneficial for side sleepers who need pressure relief.
Are these mattresses CertiPUR-US certified?
Yes, both mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified. This means the foam used in each model meets specific standards for content, emissions, and durability. You can trust that the materials are made without harmful chemicals, ensuring a safer sleep environment for you and your family.
What is the weight difference between the two models?
The BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King weighs 75 pounds. The BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen is heavier at 88 pounds. The Queen model is heavier likely due to its greater height and additional materials, which may make it slightly harder to move.
Can I sleep cooler on the BedStory 12-Inch Extra Firm Queen?
This model features a cooling gel cover to help regulate temperature. The hybrid design also promotes airflow through the pocket coils. These features work together to dissipate heat, helping you stay cooler throughout the night compared to all-foam mattresses.
Is the BedStory 10-Inch Medium Firm King easy to set up?
Yes, this mattress comes as a bed in a box. It arrives compressed and rolled, making it easy to transport to your bedroom. You simply unbox it, cut the plastic, and allow it to expand to its full 10-inch height before sleeping on it.